Monday, February 8, 2010

How could a No-Speech movement get started?

If such a movement envisioned here is possible, it will probably get going spontaneously as people who are fed up with our demagogue speech-makers take some steps to organize meetings to discuss the problem of speech-makers and how it might be possible to break free from them. There is no single leadership entity in charge of running such a movement.

If you have any thoughts on how "no-speechers" might proceed, to promote a new trend away from the domination of our society by speech-makers, click on the "comment" button and post your opinions on this.

This blog is not adequate to serve as the central point for such a new social movement, but it can serve as a means for anyone interested to make contact with others interested in this. Any websites that start up to join this "crusade" will get their link here, and hopefully someone will be able to launch something more ambitious than this blog.

Right now the need is for dialogue to clarify the idea of possibly liberating our society from the speech-makers in the future. How could it be done? What changes would be necessary? Could it be that the communication needed to carry out social action is really impossible without speech-makers dominating the process?

Why isn't it possible for social change to occur without speech-makers dominating the process?

Those interested in pursuing this are invited to use this blog as an instrument to make contact with other interested persons and consider what steps could be taken to get something going.

There may be long periods when the blog will be left unmanaged. But those interested may communicate to each other for now via the "comments".

Unfortunately you need to register with Google in order to post comments, but otherwise this forum is open to anyone without restriction.

Sunday, February 7, 2010

Should the "No Speech" movement also be an "Open Door" movement?

The "No Speech" movement should be one which starts out with no other rule than the simple condition that no speeches are to be allowed, and even this is difficult to define exactly.

Ideally there should be an openness to all points of view, such as Left-wing, Right-wing, libertarian, and so on. However, even within a particular political camp there needs to be this new form of communication, which is to discourage or even prohibit speeches, and instead find a form of communicating that does away with the dominating figure of the speaker who in effect dictates to the others present what to think and what's important.

Part of the new procedure, already practiced to some degree, will be to have longer question-and-answer sessions and shorter monologue periods. However, this is at best only a start in the right direction. Even with this limit on the speech-maker, there is too much domination by the "speaker" in choosing which questions to answer and whether to dismiss or evade questions that would expose errors in the speaker's presentation.

What is needed now is experimenting with some new procedures, to see how far we can go in establishing real communication, leading to substance or real results, while eliminating or decreasing the role of the "speaker" in the communicating process.

Such experimenting needs to take place in all kinds of groups, including partisan and ideological groups or camps. While at the same time there is a need for "open" groups, more than exist now, where all ideas are welcomed, and no one party line or agenda is given a preference to the exclusion of others.

What is a grassroots movement without "speakers"?

What will the new movement (the "no speech movement"?) look like without "speakers" to run it or speak to audiences to inspire them to action?

At this point, no one can dictate the exact procedure.

Of course meetings will be held, and communications through the Internet. Communication must take place. And it will be a higher-level communication, without the "speakers" dominating it and imposing their rhetoric onto a passive unthinking audience of sheep.

There is now no hard set of rules for this new movement, if it should take shape. Except perhaps one -- no one is allowed to speak down to the others in a monologue that lasts beyond a certain time limit, such as five minutes.

The new communicating procedure will be one of equal participation by all those present, or at least "equal opportunity" for all present to give their input, with no one "leader" being in charge to set the agenda and tell the others what to think.

Obviously there are logistical questions: Who calls a meeting? Who opens up the meeting? Who arranges the meeting location? Is there a "facilitator" rather than a "speaker"? If so, how is the facilitator chosen?

Some of the answers should be easy, and yet anyone who takes a first step is being "arbitrary" in a sense and is imposing rules onto the others. When does a short introduction, or "welcome speech" become a violation of the rule that there are to be no "speeches"? What is a "speech"?

Yet it is surely possible to get something going, based on the fundamental principle that no speeches are allowed, and then come up with rules as they are needed, and allow the necessary communication to take place while putting limits on monologues that lead to speeches or domination by one participant over others.

Enough with the Speech-makers!

The Speech makers (or "speakers") are part of the problem, not part of the solution.

America is going down the drain. A change is needed, something drastic. What will it take?

For generations we have been shackled to speech-makers to get any political grassroots movement going that could address what's wrong and how to fix it.

We need something new -- some new approach to get thinking and caring citizens involved in a process that could lead to real change.

Don't we all know that speech-makers are only good at spewing out slogans and that they offer little of substance? Aren't they really "all hat and no cattle"? Yes, they're good at manipulating an audience and inspiring people to run around mindlessly, like cattle, on a crusade that leads to nowhere. But do they really inspire genuine thinking that can lead to real change or anything of substance?

It's time to dispense with the hoopla and the demagoguery and get a grassroots movement going that drives citizens to think and communicate for real.

If you really care what's happening to the country and want to see real change, you want to do more than just cheer on a demagogue whose only talent is to manipulate you with his charisma and glamor. We've had enough of them. Can't we get something new going?

What's the first step?

Right now, the only next step is for you to add your comment here. Give your suggestion on what citizens could do right now to start some new process going that could lead to change down the line, without speech-makers.

It will take time. But haven't we had enough of the quick-fix instant-gratification schemes and promises from the mouths of speech-makers? Can't we slow down for just a moment and consider how we might find a different way of seeking the answers, and then get a process going that would eventually lead to results, even if it takes a few years -- yes, maybe even a decade or two.

It's true that America is sliding downward and may not have much time left to fix what's wrong. The "health care reform" disaster and also the sudden surge in federal deficits and the national debt are now casting doubt on the nation's future economic security.

But hopefully the decline we see will happen gradually, not in a sudden collapse, and there is time to get something going that will produce results in time to save something of the country before it's lost, and perhaps a recovery will be possible.

It should be obvious by now that the current 2-party system is failing us, as it currently operates, but also that third party movements are a hopeless cause (unless there is one that departs radically from all the previous ones, which is unlikely), and that other grassroots movements so far have been ineffective.

Something has to change somewhere. Something has to give.

Perhaps it's the institution of the speech-makers which is the obstacle to progress.

How can we find a formula for change which eliminates the speech-makers from the picture?